CoderFunda
  • Home
  • About us
    • Contact Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy
    • About us
  • Home
  • Php
  • HTML
  • CSS
  • JavaScript
    • JavaScript
    • Jquery
    • JqueryUI
    • Stock
  • SQL
  • Vue.Js
  • Python
  • Wordpress
  • C++
    • C++
    • C
  • Laravel
    • Laravel
      • Overview
      • Namespaces
      • Middleware
      • Routing
      • Configuration
      • Application Structure
      • Installation
    • Overview
  • DBMS
    • DBMS
      • PL/SQL
      • SQLite
      • MongoDB
      • Cassandra
      • MySQL
      • Oracle
      • CouchDB
      • Neo4j
      • DB2
      • Quiz
    • Overview
  • Entertainment
    • TV Series Update
    • Movie Review
    • Movie Review
  • More
    • Vue. Js
    • Php Question
    • Php Interview Question
    • Laravel Interview Question
    • SQL Interview Question
    • IAS Interview Question
    • PCS Interview Question
    • Technology
    • Other

08 May, 2023

Single controller action for POST and GET form (symfony) vs separate action (laravel) - what speaks for symfony?

 Programing Coderfunda     May 08, 2023     No comments   

symfony argues this: Rendering forms and processing forms are two of the main tasks when handling forms. Both are too similar (most of the time, almost identical), so it's much simpler to let a single controller action handle both. https://symfony.com/doc/6.0/best_practices.html#use-a-single-action-to-render-and-process-the-form now I think I disagree with it (I much seem to prefer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MF0jFKvS4SI&ab_channel=AdamWathan ). The thing is, the symfony forms ( https://symfony.com/doc/current/components/form.html ) and processing is done in a way that it simplifies actually doing it in one controller. There is no form component with laravel, and thus less incentives to reuse the same controller function (as you dont have to initialize the form component). What I saw as well a lot is that after validation failing, in symfony you dont do a redirect but instead do a rerender https://github.com/symfony/demo/blob/main/src/Controller/BlogController.php#L131 . This actually causes the user on pressing ctrl+r or refresh, to resubmit the form again which I don't think is what is intended behaviour? Is there something I am missing? What do you guys subjectively prefer? submitted by /u/Iossi_84 [link] [comments]
  • Share This:  
  •  Facebook
  •  Twitter
  •  Google+
  •  Stumble
  •  Digg
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook

Related Posts:

  • WordPress vs. Weebly WordPress vs. WeeblyIn this article, we are going to discuss the difference between WordPress and Weebly. Let us first understood about WordPres… Read More
  • WordPress vs. Webflow WordPress vs. WebflowIn this article, we are going to discuss the differences between WordPress and Webflow. Before making comparisons, we will … Read More
  • WordPress vs. Wix WordPress vs. WixWordPress and Wix are both used to create a website, but they have entirely different website creation approaches. WordPress is… Read More
  • WordPress Vs. Squarespace WordPress Vs. SquarespaceWordPress is an open-source Content Management System, whereas Squarespace is a website builder that provides Software … Read More
  • WordPress Interview Questions WordPress Interview QuestionsA list of top frequently asked WordPress interview questions and answers are given below.1) What is WordP… Read More
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Thanks

Meta

Popular Posts

  • Spring boot app (error: method getFirst()) failed to run at local machine, but can run on server
    The Spring boot app can run on the online server. Now, we want to replicate the same app at the local machine but the Spring boot jar file f...
  • Log activity in a Laravel app with Spatie/Laravel-Activitylog
      Requirements This package needs PHP 8.1+ and Laravel 9.0 or higher. The latest version of this package needs PHP 8.2+ and Laravel 8 or hig...
  • Failed to install 'cordova-plugin-firebase': CordovaError: Uh oh
    I had follow these steps to install an configure firebase to my cordova project for cloud messaging. https://medium.com/@felipepucinelli/how...
  • Laravel auth login with phone or email
          <?php     Laravel auth login with phone or email     <? php     namespace App \ Http \ Controllers \ Auth ;         use ...
  • Cashier package and Blade files
    I'm a little confused about this Cashier package. I installed it using the Laravel website (with composer), but noticed there's no...

Categories

  • Ajax (26)
  • Bootstrap (30)
  • DBMS (42)
  • HTML (12)
  • HTML5 (45)
  • JavaScript (10)
  • Jquery (34)
  • Jquery UI (2)
  • JqueryUI (32)
  • Laravel (1017)
  • Laravel Tutorials (23)
  • Laravel-Question (6)
  • Magento (9)
  • Magento 2 (95)
  • MariaDB (1)
  • MySql Tutorial (2)
  • PHP-Interview-Questions (3)
  • Php Question (13)
  • Python (36)
  • RDBMS (13)
  • SQL Tutorial (79)
  • Vue.js Tutorial (68)
  • Wordpress (150)
  • Wordpress Theme (3)
  • codeigniter (108)
  • oops (4)
  • php (853)

Social Media Links

  • Follow on Twitter
  • Like on Facebook
  • Subscribe on Youtube
  • Follow on Instagram

Pages

  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • About us

Blog Archive

  • September (100)
  • August (50)
  • July (56)
  • June (46)
  • May (59)
  • April (50)
  • March (60)
  • February (42)
  • January (53)
  • December (58)
  • November (61)
  • October (39)
  • September (36)
  • August (36)
  • July (34)
  • June (34)
  • May (36)
  • April (29)
  • March (82)
  • February (1)
  • January (8)
  • December (14)
  • November (41)
  • October (13)
  • September (5)
  • August (48)
  • July (9)
  • June (6)
  • May (119)
  • April (259)
  • March (122)
  • February (368)
  • January (33)
  • October (2)
  • July (11)
  • June (29)
  • May (25)
  • April (168)
  • March (93)
  • February (60)
  • January (28)
  • December (195)
  • November (24)
  • October (40)
  • September (55)
  • August (6)
  • July (48)
  • May (2)
  • January (2)
  • July (6)
  • June (6)
  • February (17)
  • January (69)
  • December (122)
  • November (56)
  • October (92)
  • September (76)
  • August (6)

  • Failed to install 'cordova-plugin-firebase': CordovaError: Uh oh - 9/21/2024
  • pyspark XPath Query Returns Lists Omitting Missing Values Instead of Including None - 9/20/2024
  • SQL REPL from within Python/Sqlalchemy/Psychopg2 - 9/20/2024
  • MySql Explain with Tobias Petry - 9/20/2024
  • How to combine information from different devices into one common abstract virtual disk? [closed] - 9/20/2024

Laravel News

  • Improved Installation and Frontend Hooks in Laravel Echo 2.1 - 5/15/2025
  • Filter Model Attributes with Laravel's New except() Method - 5/13/2025
  • Arr::from() Method in Laravel 12.14 - 5/14/2025
  • Streamline API Resources with Laravel's Fluent Methods - 5/13/2025
  • Customize URL Handling with Laravel's Macroable URI Class - 5/13/2025

Copyright © 2025 CoderFunda | Powered by Blogger
Design by Coderfunda | Blogger Theme by Coderfunda | Distributed By Coderfunda